MLB Fanhouse National Analyst and former Rangers scout Frank Piliere did a chat yesterday where he weighed in on some Yankee farmhands. Nothing earth shattering here, but it gives you an idea of the consensus view on some of the high profile Yankee farm products. Here’s some highlights:

1:01
[Comment From RajRaj: ]

What do you think about Hector Nosei and Gary Sanchez ? Any future with the big league club?

Wednesday June 30, 2010 1:01 Raj
1:02
Frankie Piliere:

Absolutely. Sanchez is a monster offensively and it is showing already in the GCL. Last year I really liked Noesi but didn’t see a spot for him with the Yankees. Tough to break in there unless you are a frontline guy but who knows. He’s a real good #3 for me.

1:04
[Comment From ZakZak: ]

Is Mark Melancon easily forgettable or is it just me? I’d really love for him to get a shot, especially with the Yankees bullpen struggling. Every single time he’s called up though it seems he only pitches every 10 games. What are your thoughts on him?

Wednesday June 30, 2010 1:04 Zak
1:05
Frankie Piliere:

It’s the Yankees and at some point he has to come up and make an impression quickly and show some more command. Other young relievers have broken through like Robertson by forcing their way into the mix. He has to do the same. Melancon has plus stuff but he has to show the command.

1:10
[Comment From ZakZak: ]

Brett Marshall is coming back from TJS, he’s has some electric stuff. What are the odds he fallows the Brack/Dellin line and dominants?

Wednesday June 30, 2010 1:10 Zak
1:11
Frankie Piliere:

It won’t be as simple for him I don’t think. I scouted him before he got hurt and he was 92-96 and the secondary pitches flashed plus but he was pretty crude. I like him a lot but he has a lot to work on.

1:17
[Comment From 28 in 201028 in 2010: ]

Frank, have you heard anything for the July 2 international free agency period? Specifically, who are the yankees linked to? Thanks as always Frank and great job.

Wednesday June 30, 2010 1:17 28 in 2010
1:18
Frankie Piliere:

They remain on Roughned Odor, who was also at the PG National and the Yankees were on him heavily there as were a number of clubs. This steroid scandal makes things really crazy though, still got some feelers out to see what else is happening.

1:30
[Comment From zs190zs190: ]

Sorry for so many Yankees questions but have you scouted Brackman this year, Frank? The stats look pretty darn good. The hits allowed and the ERA are high but the other important peripherals (K ratio, K/BB, groundball ratio, etc) are all excellent, are they the result of a 24 year old beating up A ball competition or has he figured it out?

Wednesday June 30, 2010 1:30 zs190
1:31
Frankie Piliere:

Scouted him in spring training and again came away unimpressed. Been about 5 different times I’ve seen him now where he hasn’t showed the plus stuff I hear about. I’m curious to see him this season because i keep hearing the big velocity is there, but I’ve heard that before so I guess we’ll see. He’s an interesting guy so I hope he has figured it out.

1:54
[Comment From 28 in 201028 in 2010: ]

Frank sorry aobut all the yankee questions, but whats your opinion on Montero catching long term?

Wednesday June 30, 2010 1:54 28 in 2010
1:54
Frankie Piliere:

I think he can do it, like I’ve said before. Now, I don’t think that means the Yankees WILL do it but he’s capable. He’d be a mediocre defender at best but he’s capable.

6 Responses to Frank Piliere on Yankee Prospects

  1. morningstar says:

    Interesting, but if you did your research you would have posted as well that his overall top 25 prospects now has Sanchez at 25, and that is very notable (even if somewhat aggressive).

    • Moshe Mandel says:

      Yeah, you are right. If he had made sure to read every article on the internet, he could have told you a lot of other stuff.

  2. Scout says:

    If he calls Montero a mediocre defender, I wonder how he’d rate Posada now.

  3. Eric Schultz says:

    3 Yankee catchers in the top 25, very impressive. I think it may be premature to rank Sanchez that highly as he’s only in rookie ball, but he has certainly looked the part so far.

  4. Reggie C. says:

    Right now i’d rank Gary Sanchez behind the 2 catchers & Brackman & Heathcott. If however Sanchez goes on to set new heights of GCL production, he’ll overtake Heathcott. In a top 100 mlb prospects list, a big gcl year should put Sanchez on the nice side of the 50 mark.

  5. Don says:

    Yesterday on another thread, I called Noesi a #4 and I really think that as of now that is what he is. To be a #3 is pretty tough. Either way, as I posted, Noesi is getting a lot of love from scouts.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

*

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Set your Twitter account name in your settings to use the TwitterBar Section.