In Ken Rosenthal’s latest, he claims that Toronto ace Roy Halladay is “all but gone” as the Blue Jays will likely trade him (I’m sure the Yankees won’t mind seeing Halladay go to another division). KR also speculates as to who the suitors will be for Halladay’s services and, surprisingly, the Yankees made the rather long list. According to KR, the “Jays will not hesitate to dangle Halladay to the Yankees and Red Sox, who will be perhaps their two most fervent suitors. A’s GM Billy Beane never rules out trading within his division. Ricciardi, Beane’s former assistant, probably would not, either.”
While I would love to see the Yankees acquire Halladay, Rosenthal believes that a package for him would consist of either Phil Hughes, Jesus Montero or Austine Romine Broken Glass ipod
(or maybe even a combination of the three). Now, even if the Blue Jays are okay with trading Halladay within their own division—a proposition I am still somewhat doubtful of—I would think that the Yankees would balk at sending Phil Hughes or Jesus Montero (who is crushing the ball in AA), in particular, to a division rival. That’s something Rosenthal seems to forget completely. There’s more risk for the Yankees in that deal as either player—Hughes or Montero—could eventually develop into a super star and haunt them for years in the AL East. For that reason, I doubt we’ll be seeing Roy Halladay in pinstripes come the trade deadline. If any team were to get him, I think it would be the Phillies although the Brewers could be a dark horse.
If you enjoyed this article, please consider sharing it!
11 Responses to Roy Halladay? Probably not…
Leave a Reply
TIQ IQ
I would give up anyone but Joba, Hughes, and Montero, although I might deal Hughes if the rest of the deal made sense.
I agree, anyone but those 3… although what do you have in mind by ‘if the rest of the deal made sense’?
If you don’t need to give up Jackson or Romine as well.
I would deal either Joba or Hughes for Halliday, plus Romine. Doc is the real deal, in the top five pitchers in the game, and it is reaosnable to assume he has another 3-4 years at his peak. Although either Joba or Hughes might someday reach that level, that is far from certain. Doc, C.C., and A.J at the front of the rotation would make any play-off foe wet his pants. With all the other catching talent in the organization, Romine is expendable. Montero looks like a superstar bat, and I would not include him, especially since the Yankees have no other hitters of comparable promise in the organization.
I would part with any player not named Joba, Hughes, Montero (Moshe and are similar, in that regard) and although Austin Jackson hasn’t shown much power, I’d keep him too. Holding onto them would probably not allow the Yankees to trade for Halladay. But, if they were willing to take Austin Romine and several other quality prospects, I’d do it in a heartbeat.
The main problem is that, although Halladay has a number of good years left, he’s only locked up at a reasonable rate through 2010. Then he becomes a free agent and could warrant a mega multi-year deal.
I agree with the post….id rather pass n let Doc head to the NL :) I wouldn’t want hughes becoming a stud and now we have a new “doc” that would haunt us…let halladay venture outside the AL. I think hughes will still blow up…he’s only 23, he’s a baby.
trade for the best pitcher in baseball, absolutely YES! give them one of the young good catchers in the farm system and a minor league arm. As far as catchers go we all know that when Mauer goes to free agency soon the Yankees will have to get him, they can’t afford to let Boston get him.
Its gonna take Ajax, ZMac, and one of the big three we’re all not trading… you’re talking, arguably, the best pitcher in baseball here. Don’t think Hank won’t be thinking hard on this one. He already got talked out of Santana.
Halladay would be an excellent pickup for any team. With him and CC on the team, the Yankees wouldn’t even need a bullpen, really, ha.
However, let’s all remember that you would only have Halladay for the rest of this season and next year. If we were talking 2-3 years, it would seem like a better option.
[...] is available then obviously any team would want him and the Yankees are no different. However, as I stated yesterday, I don’t think they will actually deal for him as it would take a bevy of young, quality [...]
I’m thinking Igawa, Kennedy and Shelley Duncan. Who could pass on that? Throw in Ransom if they want to play hardball.